Labels

Monday, November 19, 2012

Is "Doing Good" Good Enough?





In the past 15 years it has become clear that responsible practices have a huge impact on business and increasing number of companies engage in activities that not only bring profit, but they also provide positive contribution to their society and environment. The number of companies around the world that issued CSR or sustainability reports has increased from 837 in 2000 to 5,600 in 2010. The main reason for that could be explained through the words of professor Stuart Hart “The roots of the (sustainability) crisis and political and social issues exceed the mandate of any corporation. At the same time, corporations are the only organisations with the resources, the technology, the global reach and, ultimately, the motivation to achieve sustainability”. Event though there is no unique and commonly accepted definition of CSR, most companies that practice CSR describe it as giving back to the community that they operate in.

We ask ourselves the following questions: What is the real reason for companies to engage in CSR activities? Is corporate social responsibility a tool that company uses to create more value for its shareholders or is it really what it represents – giving back to the community that allowed the company to become successful in the beginning? If the real motivation for CSR is giving back to the community, why is Coca – Cola Enterprise ranked 3rd on Goodness 500 list of the most responsible companies when its main product is actually bad for consumers’ health? What kind of message can we get from the sustainability report of the biggest American chocolate producer Hershey’s, if we know that most its cocoa is sourced from the region plagued by forced labour, human trafficking, and abusive child labour and the company refuses to embrace Fair Trade certification of all of its products?





With the increase of companies that engage in CSR, this concept falls in the eyes of customers as they start to look at it as a marketing trick and doubt the real values of the company. The greenwashing concept is no longer a secret and companies cannot simply donate funds to some association or replace the light bulbs in their branches with the eco-friendly ones and call that socially responsible.

The questions that came across our minds surely came across the minds of a large number of consumers. Therefore, it is od immense importance for companies to reformulate their CSR activities and aim for accomplishing truly sustainable global community. Awareness on sustainability has already entered the mainstream of business. The challenge today is to convert the vision of sustainable world into reality (this was the main topic of annual The Business of a Better World conference, one of the biggest and most influential events dedicated to sustainable business, held last month in New York).

Today, companies need to approach their CSR activities strategically. They need to form their strategy in a way that will allow the community that it operates in to qualitatively grow together with the company in short term, but in the long term as well. This is the only way that CSR will become the source of new business opportunities and the tool to achieve sustainable competitive advantage.

We believe (and we hope!) that climate change and social responsibility issues will be the decisive factors of sustainability of future companies. If so, perhaps our children and grandchildren will not live in the world where 1 billion people lie in bed hungry every night, 800 million people don’t have access to clean water, ¾ of world’s poor don’t own a bank account and capital access and children finish school without knowing how to read, write or do basic math. The time has come for the managers to care about the future of our society and planet in order to ensure the future of their companies. 

35 comments:

  1. Odlično mi je ovo napisano, slažem se u potpunosti. I moram primjetiti s obzirom da sam pročitala još jedan blog iz istog kolegija da je vaše viđenje situacije puno realnije :))

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hvala :) potrudili smo se biti drugačiji i imati malo ozbiljniji pristup ovoj temi jer smatramo kako prostor za napredak uvijek postoji. Iako su društveno odgovorne aktivnosti pozitivna promjena, shvatili smo kako su one sve manje u očima potrošača pa želimo istaknuti potrebu poduzeća za drugačijim prostupom DOP-u od kojeg ćemo svi imati koristi. Nadamo se da vam se svidio naš blog i da ćete ga nastaviti pratiti :)

      Delete
  2. In North America there is a really scary trend for women's products called pinkwashing. It seems really similar to greenwashing, and companies that are targeting women donate money to breast cancer funds. Companies that do this are often food companies that use large amounts of preservatives and chemicals in their products, despite the damage those ingredients cause to a woman's health.

    The worst part is everyone seems to fall for it! Companies just put a little pink ribbon and donate a small portion of proceeds to a breast cancer fund, and consumers buy them in large quantities, without consideration for what these products will do to them, or what supporting these companies will do to society.

    I hope consumers will start to reward companies that use CSR effectively and honestly, whether it be for breast cancer research or climate change and social responsibility issues, as you suggest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Emily,
      Thank you for your comment. I believe what you are talking about can be seen in documentary film "Pink Ribbons". To be honest, I have never heard about pinkwashing but I can see that something very similar is happening in Croatia, as well.
      It is real hypocrisy to be donating for breast cancer, or any other cause, while at the same time doing great harm, to women, in this case.

      Keep on bloging :)

      Delete
  3. Hi!
    One of my friends liked your blog and I don't knoe how, but somehow, I got here, reading your blog! This is very interesting and I am actually taking one similar course at my school.
    I think this video would be interesting for you, as it shows many facts about CSR!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GggyVO21hw8

    Julie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Julie!
      Thank you for bloging with us and thank you for this youtube video, it will be very useful for us and our research on the topic for our future posts.
      Keep on following our blog, and share experience on CSR from your country!

      Delete
    2. Thanks for your reply! I am from Belgium, I'll definately keep on following your blog and I am actually preparing some kind of report on sustainability which sort of connected to the topic of CSR!

      Delete
    3. That's great, we hope you'll share any interesting facts with us :)

      Delete
  4. Corporate Social Responsibility is an interesting issue that has risen to the forefront of the business world recently. It presents an interesting situation because of its implications. The purpose of a business is to create profit, so it is difficult to sell the concept to shareholders. However, there have also been studies that prove that companies who engage in legitimate and honest CSR practices experience an increase in profits.

    This creates the question - if companies are not making a profit by engaging in CSR, why should they do it and how should they sell it to shareholders? And, on the other hand, if companies are making a profit, are they still being socially responsible for the "greater good" or are they now just doing it to make a profit?

    I think, because CSR is newly popular, the situation will eventually figure itself out. Consumers are getting more and more informed as time goes on, making them more aware of these dishonest CSR practices. Those companies who are effectively engaging in CSR by sharing their best practices for the greater good will succeed and CSR will eventually become more honest as a result.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Tara,

      The same question you are raising in the first part of your comment, is our concern as well. Studies has shown that many companies who engage in CSR experience an increase in sales and profits. You said in honest CSR, but what about those who engage in dishonest CSR and still experience an increase in profits. Consumers in Croatia are still "blind" on those companies, and the only factor on deciding where to buy some product is, unfortunately, price and not CSR practice of the company. I advise you to watch "Pink Ribbon" documentary and discuss with us Emily's post about pink washing effect and share experience from your country!

      Keep on blogging :)

      Delete
  5. In recent years, CSR has become more important every year in North America and especialy in Canada, where the economy is driven by natural resources. People are now more aware of the effects caused by the exploitation of these resources and companies are than forced to implement CSR practices to legetimate the fact that they are affecting the environment. A good example is a company like Domtar(a paper producer) which has called itself the sustainable paper company: http://www.domtar.com/

    Another good example is with the oil sands producer Syncrude, which also has CSR practices: http://www.cdnoilsands.com/sustainability/default.aspx

    Could this only be a communication strategy to hide the fact that they are heavily polluting? Probably, but it might also be positive since these companies make at least some efforts to collect their resources intelligently.

    It could therefore be a win-win situation for companies and consumers when using CSR. The companies would gain an improved brand image, which with the oil sands means selling their product to the U.S where it is considered dirty. Meanwhile, the consumers would get an improved and safer environment.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Nicolas,

      thank you for sharing your country's experience with us. We are very happy to have diverse views on CSR on our blog. From other people's experiences we can see that we all have similar opinions on CSR, even though we live in different cultures and have different resources. We find this topic very important as it will present a considerable part of every company in close future. It is very interesting to see how different countries use different CSR strategies - which brings us to our key point - companies should care about improving the community that they operate in and find the best possible way to allow the community to grow with the company.

      Keep on blogging :)

      Delete
  6. There has been a growing trend of CSR in Kenya over the past few years, with a lot of companies helping in donating for charitable activities. However, I feel that these activities, while helping the immediate cause, lack a long term view, in attempting to help the less fortunate by breaking out of the poverty cycle through funding infrastructure or education. Hence I believe there is a lot of room for growth in this new trend of CSR, not only in numbers, but also quality.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Shailen, thanks for sharing the situation in Kenya with us, it is certanly interesting to find out how things are across the globe. We also believe that there is room for improvements and that, although any charitable action is more than welcome, there should be a long term aspect, which will ensure sustainability of those actions in the community.

      Delete
  7. What is the real reason for companies to engage in CSR activities?? In Croatia it is still only for PR purposes....Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Ana, we do agree that in they still mostly do it for good reputation, but there are other reasons too, as there are many companies that have socially responsible activities non familiar to the public. One of the reasons are certainly employees, as many people nowadays prefer working for socially responsible companies. Let's hope in the future more and more companies will do it just for the sake of giving back to the community :)

      Delete
  8. Hi

    What a great blog on a very important topic!

    One of the changes I am experiencing in Denmark as Head of HR and therefore responsible of all recruitments, is an increasing demand from candidates! I see a tendency in the new generation of employees having a very strong opinion on the CSR strategy in our company. Besides the usual questions candidates might ask concerning salary, working terms etc. many from the younger generation want to know if they will become part of a company who takes responsibility! I recruit in all the Scandinavian countries and I can see that working in a CSR oriented organization definitely has a strong 'cool factor'! This puts a new angle and demand to companies considering their CSR strategy - and how cool is that?!!! :-)

    Kind Regards Pernille, Nordic Manager Quality and People, Falck TravelCare





    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Pernille, we completely agree with you. It really is great companies need to have CSR strategies in order to attract and retain talents. That's definitely becoming a new trend, showing that soon this will be a necessity. Thank you for your comment :)

      Delete
  9. Hi there!

    Great topic to start a debate, as I believe the most things you mentioned are completely true, but you just can't check them out.
    Why? Because we are living in a world of lies and virtual values. For example, Coca-cola company's worth is mostly consisted of it's "goodwill". So, the question rises, how to control and constantly check the truth of goodwill's value?

    Considering what I wrote above, you can easily conclude that the situation with companies engaging CSR activities is roughly the same. They all want to engage, because of it's current trend and popularity (and many other benefits as well), but they really don't even care. The problem is how to find out who cares and who doesn't?

    Today, the whole market is about pumping it's virtual values to it's maximum level, not thinking about the fact that the bubble we're into right now might as well burst when we reach our maximum. This includes the companies supposedly care about society as much as they are willing to invest in it, "for the greater good". The thing we forgot is that companies really care only about their own success and profit, and actually they are investing in their future, not ours.

    Best wishes,

    Velebit Mirić

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Velebit, firs of all thank you for sharing your thoughts with us. We agree, it really is almost imposible to track reasons behind behaving socially responsible. Not many companies do it just for the great good, that's for sure. Anyway, what we can do is take the most of it, after all, even if they do it for the questionable reasons, it is still better that they don' do it at all :) we hope youll share some more thoughts with us in our next blog :)

      Delete
  10. Hi there!
    I have been thinking, ever since I read your blog, about the name of your blog and how I actually like it a lot :)
    I have been thinking about the background of that name, and would appreciate very much if you could explain it further than mentioned in your blog post...

    Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Johny, thank for your positive feedback regarding our name :)
      What actually inspired us when we were thinking about the name, was the fact that "corporate social responsibility" is not just a simple term anymore. It's not just about companies doing good, but about companies realizing that this is an important part of their strategie that could result in many benefits in terms of their reputation, employees, government, society they operate in, and other stakeholders, but also in terms of finacial result. We hope this clears it a bit for you and that you'll continue on reading our future posts :)

      Delete
    2. Thanks! It was clear enough even before, just wanted to double check if my thoughts on this are the same as yours!
      Keep up the good work :)

      Delete
  11. Hi!
    I am from Spain and, I am sure you know about it, but there is huge crisis still and we are not recovering really... In these conditions of crisis it is really hard to engage fully in CSR activities and donate money or do anything that involves money. Are there any CSR activites that can be done and are useful even without donating and can we engage in some other way?
    Thanks,
    J.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Jose, you can engage your emloyees and per example collect books for children you can then donate, you can organize some workshops for unemployeed, where your experts can give them some useful advices... Those are just two examples, but there are other ways you can help your community, that doesn't involve money :)

      Delete
    2. Thanks a lot! It is very interesting for me to see that there are many possibilities of doing CSR activities :)
      Thanks,
      J.

      Delete
  12. Hi!!

    I come from Ecuador and we have a very interesting story with CSR. In the 70s, we started exporting petroleum. This brought infrastructure and business development to Ecuador which was very good for our national development. However, it also brought corruption, bad practices in stakeholder management (disrespect of international companies for indigenous people) as well as environmental challenges. Eventually, we found ourselves in ethical crisis, which led to the abandonment of our corrupted national currency and deepest economic crisis ever. Our civil society was so angry that three presidents were forced to leave office in 10 years. THese political changes have created space for the development of the CSR, or as we call it here in Ecuador “MINGA”. The base of the governance solution found by the political structure created in Ecuador is the new Constitution of the Republic: one that gives rights to citizens, nature, and re-concentrates the power in the hands of the State. The new generation of Entrepreneurs is now forced to find solutions to management that involve the creation of new relations, where competitiveness had to be based in good relations with stakeholders and the will to abandon bad practices related to environment, society and the economy.

    We still have corruption, our economy is not growing very fast and inequality did not disappear. But it is politically incorrect to show and promote any enterprise as an insensible structure, or as a machine of making money or generating profits in Ecuador. I believe that this will bring honest investors who want to do business responsibly and sustainably which will allow us to grow even more and overcome the challenges I mentioned earlier.

    Good work with the blog. It is really interesting to hear about different CSR practices in different countries.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dear Diego,
    thank you for sharing the situation in Ecuador with us. We agree with you, it's very interesting to hear about use of CSR in different countries and we learned a lot from your comment. That was really one of our biggest wishes when we started this blog,so thank you once more. We have to say that the situation in Croatia is very similar regarding corruption and inequality,and we hope that use of CSR will improve the state of economy in both our countries. We hope you'll keep reading our blog and maybe share more of your thoughts with us :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. I come from China and it is very difficult with international corporation in my country. They come and pay little to workers and they use them. This is main reason they do business in China. I know it bring benefit to our economy but I also know they using us. The situation could been better in China if these companys only care about our economy and not only profit. And than they advertise as socially responsible because they did something good in their home country. And what about China? And this is the proof that they only have interest in profit. It is so sad. I hope this will change in future.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Siyun, we agree with you. It is sad that in 21st century things like that still happen. We do, however, believe that all this companies will be forced to change their policies in future, as a result of globalisation. People around the globe are becoming more and more aware of this problem, and more and more non government organisation are dealing with this issue. That, of course, has an impact on companies, because they don't want to be the "bed guys" in the media and that way ruin their reputation. We sincerely hope situation will become better in China, but also other countries in the world. Thank you and we hope you'll continue on following our blog :)

      Delete
    2. I hope so too. That is one of the reasons I study in Australia. I hope to find some soulution to this problem and hope to make China one of the most sustainable country in the world. Because now I scare that companies will only use China and when we increase our salaries then they will abandon us and find some other country to use for profit. I study economics and I hope it will help. It is good to know that a small country in Europe is aware of this problem that China has. I hope other countries are too

      Delete
    3. We hope so to. However, as long as there are people like you and us, who recognise this problem, we believe there's a bright future ahead :)

      Delete
  15. I had to do a work presentation about Corporate Social Responsability for corporate strategy and this blog helped me a lot!
    Even if there's not a specific definition for CSR, this blog made me think a lot before doing my presentation, specially in all the situations that was mentioned, like Coca-Cola and Hershey’s...
    I also enjoyed how the text is written in a way that seems we are truly speaking with someone, in a real discussion about CSR!
    Great blog! ;) Keep posting!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Francisco,

      we are very happy that you found some useful information for your presentation on our blog. And we are even more happy that we encouraged you to think about this topic. An interesting fact is that there is no commonly agreed upon definition of CSR, even though it is a subject of so many studies.
      Keep on blogging :)

      Delete
  16. Recently I came back from Mexico and I believe that this topic is getting more and more important in emerging markets. For example, the runner up supermarket chain named Soriana is using "green" marketing strategy, and the research has shown that it is actually improving sales of course at the expense of the market leader.

    So green can really help boost sales! Excellent blog

    ReplyDelete